The Evolution of MLS Greats: Ranking the Top 20 Players of All Time

The 20 Greatest MLS Players of All Time: A Ranking Analysis

Introduction

Interest in Major League Soccer (MLS) has reached new heights with the recent move of Lionel Messi to Inter Miami. This has sparked discussions about the greatest players in MLS history, taking into account their careers in the league rather than their achievements elsewhere. In this article, we will analyze the rankings of the 20 greatest MLS players of all time, as ranked by GIVEMESPORT.

Methodology

GIVEMESPORT has based their rankings solely on the players’ performances in the MLS, disregarding their accomplishments outside of the league. While this approach may be controversial, it allows for an objective assessment of their impact and influence on the MLS.

The Top 5: Donovan, Wondolowski, Giovinco, Beckham, Keane

Claiming the top spot is Landon Donovan, widely recognized as one of the greatest American players in football history. Donovan’s scoring ability, creativity, and leadership played a crucial role in LA Galaxy’s success. His record of 144 goals in 340 games, coupled with six MLS Cup titles, solidifies his status as the league’s best player.

Chris Wondolowski, the former San Jose Earthquakes striker, comes in at second place. With a record-breaking 171 goals in 413 games, Wondolowski’s clinical finishing and consistency have made him a legend in MLS.

Sebastian Giovinco, known as ‘The Atomic Ant,’ occupies the third spot. His time at Toronto FC saw him score 68 goals in 114 games, leading the club to its first MLS Cup. Giovinco’s speed, technical skills, and goal-scoring prowess made a significant impact on MLS.

David Beckham, a global football icon, ranks fourth on the list. While his on-field contributions with LA Galaxy were notable, scoring 18 goals in 98 games, it is his off-field influence that truly transformed the league. Beckham’s star power raised the league’s profile internationally and remains a defining moment in MLS history.

Completing the top five is Robbie Keane, whose predatory instincts, leadership, and big-game performances guided LA Galaxy to MLS dominance during his tenure. Keane’s 83 goals in 125 games showcased his ability to be a top striker, even towards the end of his career.

Philosophical Discussion: The Evolution of MLS

The rankings highlight the evolution of MLS over the years. The presence of established football stars like Messi, Ibrahimovic, and Beckham has attracted global attention, enhancing the league’s reputation. While the rankings solely consider players’ performances within MLS, it is crucial to acknowledge the impact of these high-profile signings in further advancing the league’s growth and development.

MLS has evolved from a fledgling league struggling for recognition to a competitive and reputable competition. The inclusion of players such as Giovinco, Beckham, and Keane underscores the league’s ability to attract top talent and compete on an international stage. Their contributions both on and off the field have played a significant role in the league’s rise in popularity.

Editorial: Debating the Rankings

Rankings are inherently subjective, and there will always be room for debate. While GIVEMESPORT’s rankings provide a valuable perspective on the greatest MLS players based on their performances in the league, there are arguments to be made for other players who may not have made the list.

Some notable omissions from the top 20 include Thierry Henry, Zlatan Ibrahimovic, and Josef Martinez, all of whom have made significant contributions to their respective clubs and left a lasting impact on the league. However, their exclusion does not diminish their individual achievements or impact on MLS.

It is essential to remember that rankings are subjective opinions and should not be the sole determinant of a player’s greatness. Each player brings their unique qualities and influences the game in different ways. Ultimately, the greatness of a player cannot be distilled purely based on statistics but also through their influence, legacy, and impact on the league.

Advice for Future Rankings

When considering future rankings of the greatest MLS players, it is important to strike a balance between statistical achievements and intangible qualities. Evaluating a player’s impact, influence, and legacy on the league beyond mere numbers will provide a more comprehensive understanding of their greatness.

Additionally, acknowledging the impact of international players who have chosen to showcase their talents in MLS, like Messi and Ibrahimovic, adds another layer of discussion and appreciation for their contributions to the league’s growth and global reputation.

Ultimately, rankings serve as a starting point for conversation and reflection on the players who have made MLS what it is today. As the league continues to evolve and attract top talent, future iterations of these rankings will surely spark further debate and discussion among fans and analysts alike.