Rachel Zegler and Snow White: Navigating Controversy and Celebrating Diversity

The Controversy Surrounding Rachel Zegler and the Snow White Remake

The Backlash and Its Origins

Rachel Zegler, the lead actor in Disney’s upcoming live-action Snow White remake, has recently come under scrutiny for comments she made about the original 1937 animated film. These comments, which resurfaced on TikTok and gained viral attention, have sparked a heated debate online.

One of the criticisms directed at Zegler revolves around her childhood memories of watching the original Snow White. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly in December 2022, she expressed that she was scared of the original version and was only able to watch it once. She also mentioned being terrified of the Snow White attraction at Disney World. These comments have raised concerns among some fans, who view them as disrespectful towards the beloved classic.

Another aspect of the controversy stems from changes made to the script of the remake. Zegler has revealed that the focus will be shifted away from the original storyline, which includes a love story where the prince essentially stalks Snow White. Instead, the new version intends to empower Snow White as a leader, removing the traditional prince-centric plot. While these changes have positive implications for feminist representation, they have triggered backlash from some who argue that not all women aspire to be leaders and that criticizing Disney princesses does not align with feminist values.

The Criticism on TikTok and Public Response

The backlash against Zegler gained momentum due to multiple TikTok videos criticizing her comments and casting choices. In one viral video, a user named @CosyWithAngie argued that it is not anti-feminist for women to desire love, marriage, or traditional gender roles. The user expressed the importance of representing diverse perspectives and warned against trying to fit women into a singular image of worthiness.

In another viral video, criticism was directed at Zegler for accepting the lead role in the remake despite supposedly disliking the original film. This video questioned the motivations behind her involvement and labeled it as “fake feminism.”

While Zegler has yet to address the controversy directly, she has received support from others within the industry. Dr. Robyn Muir, a lecturer at Surrey University specializing in Disney princesses, defended Zegler, highlighting the unfair backlash she has faced. Dr. Muir emphasized that love and feminism are not mutually exclusive and promoted the need for a more nuanced understanding of gender representation.

Racial Controversy and the Snow White Remake

This is not the first time the Snow White remake has been at the center of controversy. Prior to the backlash aimed at Zegler, there were racist comments made when it was announced that she would portray the lead role. Zegler, who is of Colombian and Polish descent, addressed these comments on social media, reminding everyone that every child deserves to see themselves as a princess, regardless of their race or ethnicity.

Additionally, there has been discussion about the film‘s rebranding and the decision to replace the original characters known as the “dwarfs.” The remake, simply titled Snow White, features only one actor with dwarfism among Snow White’s on-screen mining companions. This decision sparked contrasting opinions, with Peter Dinklage, an actor with dwarfism, stating that including the seven dwarfs in the remake would be regressive. However, others argued that Dinklage’s view does not represent the entire dwarf community and called for more opportunities for dwarf actors in Hollywood.

Disney Remakes and Modernization

Disney has a history of updating its classic princess stories for modern audiences. The live-action remakes of The Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast included tweaks to make the characters more independent and reflective of contemporary values. Emma Watson’s portrayal of Belle showcased her as an inventor with agency, while Halle Bailey’s Ariel had a story that extended beyond her desire for a prince.

Just like Zegler, Halle Bailey also faced racist comments when it was announced she would play Ariel. In a Variety interview, she emphasized the importance of representation and the impact it can have on young girls, stating that there is no reason why they shouldn’t be princesses in every way.

Editorial: The Wider Implications and Moving Forward

The controversy surrounding Rachel Zegler and the Snow White remake raises important questions about representation, feminism, and the power dynamics within Hollywood. It highlights the ongoing struggle to redefine and expand the roles and narratives for female characters, and the challenges faced when trying to meet the expectations of a diverse audience.

On one hand, it is crucial to recognize and respect differing perspectives on love, relationships, and independence. While some may prefer traditional gender roles and find value in stories that reflect those choices, others find empowerment in narratives that challenge traditional norms. The goal should be to embrace a broad range of experiences and viewpoints instead of perpetuating a singular image of female worthiness.

It is also essential to address the systemic issues of sexism and racism that persist in the entertainment industry. The racist comments directed at Zegler and Bailey are a stark reminder of the work that remains to be done to create a more inclusive and equitable Hollywood.

Disney, as a powerful influence in the entertainment industry, has a responsibility to ensure that its adaptations and remakes provide fair representation and challenge outdated narratives. By updating classic stories to reflect the values and aspirations of diverse audiences, Disney has the opportunity to shape the perceptions and expectations of future generations.

Moving forward, it is crucial for Hollywood to engage in open and constructive dialogue with its audience. The voices of fans and critics should be heard and valued, allowing for a more inclusive and nuanced approach to storytelling.

Advice: Navigating Controversies and Celebrating Diversity

For Fans and Audiences

When engaging with controversies surrounding films and artists, it is important to approach them with an open mind and a willingness to listen. Different viewpoints and experiences can coexist, and understanding and empathy are crucial for fostering meaningful conversations.

Recognize that discussions about representation and feminism are complex and multifaceted. It is not about dismissing or diminishing one person’s beliefs or preferences, but rather embracing the diversity of perspectives and allowing space for different stories to be told.

Support films and artists that champion diversity and challenge stereotypes. Celebrate stories that provide a platform for underrepresented voices and encourage Hollywood to continue diversifying its narratives.

For Filmmakers and the Entertainment Industry

Engage in open dialogue with audiences and critics, listening to their concerns and feedback. Use controversies as an opportunity to understand the evolving expectations and desires of diverse audiences.

Create space for underrepresented communities, both in front of and behind the camera. Embrace diverse perspectives and collaborate with artists from different backgrounds to ensure authentic and inclusive storytelling.

Continuously educate yourself and be willing to learn from past mistakes. Recognize the power of media in shaping societal norms and challenge outdated narratives by promoting stories that celebrate diversity and empowerment.

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding Rachel Zegler and the Snow White remake serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggle to achieve inclusivity and representation in Hollywood. By engaging with these discussions and taking positive action, the entertainment industry can play a vital role in shaping a more equitable and diverse future.