Exploring Nordic Links: Orkney Council Considers Alternative Pathways

Orkney to explore ‘Nordic links’ as council ponders other forms of governance

The Orkney Islands Council is undertaking a discussion regarding alternative forms of governance that could potentially change the legal status of the islands. Council leader James Stockan has proposed a motion to explore different forms of governance that could create more economic opportunities for Orkney. One suggestion is to look at crown dependencies like Guernsey, Jersey, and the Isle of Man. Additionally, the report being presented to the council mentions the possibility of “Nordic connections,” specifically referencing the Faroe Islands, a self-governing territory of Denmark in the North Sea.

Searching for new opportunities

Council leader James Stockan’s motion is not a commitment to any particular form of governance. The report from officials acknowledges that any constitutional change would likely require a combination of petitions, referenda, and legislation at both Holyrood and Westminster. The discussion stems from Stockan’s belief that Orkney is currently being “failed dreadfully” by both the Edinburgh and London governments. He highlights the fact that funding per head is lower for Orkney compared to Shetland and the Western Isles.

Ancient history and cultural affinity

Orkney has a rich history, formerly under Norwegian and Danish control before becoming part of Scotland in 1472. Stockan points out that Orkney spent more time as part of the Norse kingdom than as part of the United Kingdom. He cites the sentiments of Orkney residents who express a desire to “pay back the dowry” and return to their Norse roots. This proposal aims to explore the deep cultural connection and affinity between Orkney and the Nordic countries.

A balancing act

While many are supportive of empowering island communities, there are concerns about potential barriers that may arise from pursuing alternative pathways. Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP for Orkney, Liam McArthur, expressed interest in learning more about the proposed plans and their differences from previous proposals. He stressed the importance of ensuring that local resources are not diverted from essential services, particularly considering the pressures they currently face.

Overall, the Orkney Islands Council’s exploration of alternative forms of governance reflects a desire for greater economic opportunity, fairer funding, and a recognition of the region’s historical and cultural ties. However, it is crucial to strike a balance between pursuing new avenues and not overlooking the day-to-day needs of the community. As this discussion unfolds, it will be essential to listen to the perspectives of Orkney residents and carefully consider the potential benefits and challenges associated with any changes to the islands’ governance.