“An Unfiltered Assessment: The Controversial and Humorously Challenging Bill Burr’s ‘Old Dads’ on Netflix”

Old Dads Review: A Bitter Misfire of Bill Burr’s Directorial Debut

Introduction

In his directorial debut, comedian Bill Burr has unfortunately missed the mark with the Netflix comedy film “Old Dads.” The film, which revolves around three older fathers rebelling against political correctness, falls flat with its bitter humor and lack of comedic substance.

Apatovian Influence

The film seems to draw inspiration from the works of Judd Apatow, who has successfully portrayed the journey of men growing up and taking on responsibility in his films. However, while Apatow’s characters have come to realize the need to mature and provide for their loved ones, the ensemble in “Old Dads” longs for a past where they could get away with anything, before what they perceive as the invasion of political correctness.

Rejecting the Onward March of Time

As middle-aged men, the protagonists of “Old Dads” find themselves at a crossroads. Having sold their throwback jersey retailer, they now face unemployment and the challenges of parenthood. The film explores their struggle to adapt and avoid a bleak future, often resorting to a Vegas road trip borrowed from Apatow’s “Knocked Up.” It becomes clear that despite their resistance, they will eventually have to come to terms with the changing times.

Burr’s Script and Performances

Bill Burr, a seasoned standup comedian known for his prickly comic powers, co-authored the script with Ben Tishler. However, the dialogue often feels like stale gripes and observations, lacking the comedic punch that Burr is capable of delivering on stage. The film’s attempts at humor rely on reactionary takes and tired stereotypes, failing to provide genuine laughter.

While Bobby Cannavale and Bokeem Woodbine deliver solid performances as well-meaning characters, Burr’s portrayal of the curmudgeonly Jack stands out with his bitter edge. Yet, his character stops short of overt hatefulness, constantly radiating annoyance with everything. There are moments when Burr’s familiar righteousness shines through, shedding light on the motivations for his resistance to political correctness.

A Cynical View on Respecting Others

Through Jack’s character, the film challenges the idea of respecting others solely out of fear of social ostracism rather than genuine virtue. This cynical perspective may resonate with some viewers, but it also highlights the film’s overall lack of depth and failure to provide meaningful insights.

A Dated Take on Manhood

“Old Dads” shares similarities with the TV show “Entourage,” both sharing a dated perspective on manhood. Both address the fear of mortality and the reluctance to give up aspects of youth in order to embrace adulthood. While this theme is more noticeable in Burr’s film, it does not offer much beyond superficial character growth and the realization that voicing frustrations privately is less troublesome than confronting others with hostility.

A Lackluster Comedy

While impotent anger can be a comedic staple, “Old Dads” fails to deliver humor that surpasses dull cultural criticisms and controversial topics. The film’s attempts at humor and its reliance on anger and bitterness fall short, leaving the audience wanting for more.

Conclusion

“Old Dads” is a disappointing misfire in Bill Burr’s directorial debut. Despite an intriguing premise and potential for a meaningful exploration of aging and the challenges of parenthood, the film lacks comedic substance, relying on tired stereotypes and bitter humor. While Burr’s character provides moments of genuine reflection, they are overshadowed by the overall lack of depth and wit in the film. “Old Dads” disappoints, leaving viewers wanting for a comedy that is both funny and thought-provoking.